Automation ROI Calculator
Compare manual cost against automation savings and ROI.
Compare manual cost against automation savings and ROI. Enter your numbers and get an instant result.
This page compares the yearly cost of doing a task by hand with the first-year cost of automating it, and reports the hours saved, the money saved and a single return-on-investment percentage.
It needs five numbers: minutes per run, runs per week, an hourly labour rate, a one-off development cost and an annual maintenance cost. The yearly manual figure assumes 52 working weeks at the same volume.
The arithmetic is one multiplication chain per line in the tab. There is no discounting, no ramp-up curve and no per-seat pricing, so the percentage is a first-year comparison rather than a business case.
The four lines of arithmetic
Annual hours are minutes divided by 60, times runs per week, times 52. Fifteen minutes at twenty runs a week is 260 hours a year.
Annual manual cost is those hours times the hourly rate. The automation side of year one is the development cost plus one year of maintenance, which is why a large build cost can make the first year negative.
Savings are the manual cost minus that year-one automation cost, and the percentage is savings divided by the automation cost, times 100. When the automation cost is zero the percentage is reported as zero rather than divided by zero.
- Hours: minutes / 60 * runs per week * 52
- Manual cost: hours * hourly rate
- Year one: development cost + maintenance cost
- Return: (manual cost - year one) / year one * 100
The costs it does not model
A build has a ramp: the first months are slower than the manual process while the automation is debugged, and that period is not in the model.
The model also ignores what the freed hours are worth. Twenty hours a week of data entry and twenty hours of client work cost the same at one hourly rate, but only one of them converts into revenue.
How to use the five cost fields
Fill the five Manual Task Metrics and Automation Costs fields: Minutes Spent Per Task, Task Runs Per Week, Employee Hourly Rate, Development Setup Cost and Annual Maintenance Cost. The yearly manual figure assumes 52 working weeks at the same volume.
Read the ROI Analysis for hours saved, money saved and the single return percentage. It is a first-year comparison with no discounting and no ramp-up curve, not a full business case.
What to Expect
Best for
- A first pass on whether a repeatable task is worth scripting
- Explaining to a manager why a large build cost delays the payback
- Comparing two tasks at the same hourly rate
Not ideal for
- A business case that needs discounted cash flow or a multi-year view
- Tasks whose volume changes seasonally, since one weekly figure is assumed flat
- Estimating the build cost itself, which is an input and never a suggestion
What this tool keeps
- 52 weeks as the year, applied to the same weekly volume every week
- The development cost counted once and the maintenance cost counted once
- A negative return shown as negative rather than clamped to zero
What may need cleanup
- The hourly rate, which should include overhead if the saving is meant to be a real cost
- The maintenance estimate, which is the figure most often guessed low
- A first-year verdict that ignores the months before the automation is reliable
Common errors
- Entering an annual maintenance figure and expecting it multiplied by the years modelled
- Reading the percentage as a lifetime return rather than year one
- Using a billable rate for internal admin time and overstating the saving
Example use cases
- Deciding whether to script a weekly report
- Arguing for or against paying for an integration
- Comparing a cheap tool with a large one-off build
Sample input
15 minutes a task, 20 runs a week, $25 an hour, $1,500 to build and $200 a year to maintain.
Sample output
260.0 hours a year, $6,500.00 of manual labour, $4,800.00 saved and a 282.4% first-year return.
Who this is for
- Operations leads weighing a script against a manual routine
- Founders sizing a first automation
- Analysts who need a payback figure they can defend line by line
Frequently asked questions
What does the ROI figure compare?
The yearly cost of doing a task by hand with the first-year cost of automating it, reporting the hours saved, the money saved and one return-on-investment percentage.
Does it model a multi-year business case?
No. It uses 52 weeks at a flat weekly volume, counts development once and maintenance once, and does not discount cash flow.
Why can the result be negative?
A negative return is shown as negative rather than clamped to zero, because the first-year cost can exceed the saving.
Build custom tools for your store
Join the SDK program to create useful ecommerce utilities for your store.